Studying
Religion in
Culture

Faculty & Staff
About Us
Degrees
Courses

Events
Links
Contact

UA Home
Students' Desk
Home


REL 480
THE HISTORY OF RELIGIOUS EXPERIENCE


Dr. Russell McCutcheon
E-mail: russell.mccutcheon@ua.edu
Time: M 3:00-5:30
Location: Manly 210
Office: Manly 211
Office Hour: TBA


Who's who and
what's what?

Click and find out...


Films

As part of the course we will be seeing the following films, some outside of regular class time.

   


About Online Readings

The online readings for this course are posted in the form of PDF files (Portable Document Format), stored on the Department's "secure" server, and are therefore not freely available on the Internet.

To open these files you must click on the links and, when prompted, enter your Bama ID and Password.

If you have forgotten your Bama ID, but know your Campus Wide ID (CWID), then please go here. If you still have difficulty accessing these readings, then contact the instructor by email.

Those who need to download Adobe Acrobat Reader 6.0 to open PDFs (a free software available on the web and which is already installed on all campus computers) can go here.

Note: larger PDFs can take a long time to download (due to a slow Internet connection) and a long time to print (depending on your printer). Some students may therefore wish to download these files in a computer lab on campus, and then either print them there or store them on a floppy disk or zip/junk drive (to read/print them later at home).

"You don't even know what I am, Dad, you don't know who I am. You don't know how I feel, what I think."

So said the actor Sidney Poitier playing one of the leading roles in 1967's "Guess Who's Coming to Dinner." This is a common enough rhetoric with which most people can identify--one that effectively constructs an autonomy for one social actor by asserting the existence of a core of private feeling unavailable to others. In this case it is the son, working to create his own sense of self apart from that of his parents, their values, and their expectations for him (and who he will marry!). Much like claims concerning this thing we term "the American experience," this rhetoric reinforces a presumption that, despite the changes in historical circumstance, some inner, original, and therefore authentic, thing forever remains the same and can be identified to exist in multiple persons. Sometimes we call it "identity," sometimes "experience," and sometimes it goes by the name of "human nature."

This senior-level seminar examines the role played by these assumptions in the history of the study of religion--a field which, from the outset, is presumed to study the many different manifestations of a single, unified thing: "religious experience." Beginning with the influential work of the eighteenth-century German theologian, Friedrich Schleiermacher and the writings of the nineteenth-century U.S psychologist of religion, William James (who delivered the famous Gifford Lectures), the course charts the development of a humanistic discourse on religion up to the present, represented by such writers as Charles Taylor--the noted moral philosopher--and Diana Eck--who leads Harvard University's Pluralism Project, which is charting the contours of American religious experience.

After surveying some notable members of the humanistic tradition (up to the present), the course changes focus and offers several examples of current scholarship that historicizes claims to experiential authenticity and socio-political autonomy characteristic of the humanistic tradition. Among others, students will therefore be introduced to the critical work of such writers as the U.S. philosopher of religion, Wayne Proudfoot, the U.S. feminist historian, Joan Wallach Scott, the Berkeley scholar of Buddhist Studies, Robert Sharf, the British Marxist historian, E. P. Thompson, the French postmodernist, Michel Foucault, the U.S. gender theorist, Judith Butler, along with the Slovenia intellectual, Slavoj Zizek and our Department's own semiotician, Tim Murphy, who examines the type of subjectivity characteristic of our field--at best represented in the work of the University of Chicago's influential scholar, the late Mircea Eliade.


Syllabus

Spring 2008 (PDF)


Books

Judith Butler, Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity. Routledge Press, 1999

Michel Foucault, A History of Sexuality: An Introduction. Vol. 1. Vintage, 1990

Russell McCutcheon, Religion and the Domestication of Dissent, or How to Live in a Less than Perfect Nation. Equinox, 2005.

Slavoj Zizek, Welcome to the Desert of the Real. Verso, 2002.


Readings

Course readings are posted on this page as PDFs. For further information on opening these files, see the section to the bottom left, "About Online Readings." Consult the syllabus to determine when we will tackle each of the following readings.

Robert Dejarlais
"Shelter Blues: Sanity and Selfhood Among the Homeless"

Diana Eck
"Bozeman to Banaras: Questions from the Passage to India"

William James
"The Varieties of Religious Experience: A Study in Human Nature"

Russell McCutcheon
General Introduction: Religious Experience: A Reader

Tim Murphy
"Eliade, Subjectivity, and Hermeneutics"

Wayne Proudfoot
"Religious Experience"

Friedrich Schleiermacher
"On Religion: Speeches to its Cultured Despisers"

Joan Wallach Scott
"The Evidence of Experience"

Robert Sharf
"Buddhist Modernism and the Rhetoric of Meditative Experience"

Ann Taves
Excerpt from Fits, Trances, and Visions

Charles Taylor
"Varieties of Religious Experience"

E.P. Thompson
"The Transforming Power of the Cross"

Joachim Wach
"Universals in Religion"

Raymond Williams
"Experience"


Visit Studying Religion

Looking for an overview on "religious experience"? Consider this article from the encyclopedia of Religion.


Origins and the Olympics


Two Case Studies in
Words Shaping Reality and
the Reality of Words

The War on Terror vs. the Struggle Against Violent Extremism